What Is Peritoneal Dialysis?
Peritoneal dialysis (PD) is a treatment for kidney failure that uses the lining of your abdomen - the peritoneum - as a natural filter. Instead of going to a clinic three times a week for hemodialysis, you do it yourself at home. A soft tube (catheter) is placed in your belly during a simple surgery. Dialysis fluid flows in through this tube, pulls out waste and extra fluid from your blood, then drains out. It’s not as invasive as hemodialysis, and it gives you more control over your schedule.
There are two main types of peritoneal dialysis done at home: Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis (CAPD) and Automated Peritoneal Dialysis (APD). Both work the same way, but how and when you do the exchanges is very different. Choosing between them isn’t just about convenience - it affects your sleep, your energy, your risk of infection, and even your ability to keep working.
CAPD: Manual Exchanges, Daytime Freedom
CAPD doesn’t need a machine. You do the exchanges yourself, by hand, 3 to 5 times a day. Each exchange takes about 30 to 40 minutes. You hang a bag of dialysis fluid from a pole, let it drain into your belly by gravity, let it sit for a few hours to pull out toxins, then drain it out into a collection bag. You can walk around while the fluid is in your belly - hence the name “ambulatory.”
That means you can do it during your lunch break, while watching TV, or even while traveling. Many people who use CAPD say it gives them the most freedom during the day. One teacher in Sydney told me he does his exchanges between classes. No alarms, no machines, just a bag in his backpack and a clean space to swap it out.
But there’s a catch. You have to be physically able to handle the bags, connect the tubing, and follow sterile technique every single time. That’s hard if you have arthritis, shaky hands, or vision problems. And because you’re doing it manually, there’s a higher risk of introducing bacteria - which can lead to peritonitis, a serious belly infection. Studies show CAPD users have about 0.68 infections per year, compared to 0.52 for APD users.
APD: Nighttime Automation, Fewer Daytime Interruptions
APD uses a machine called a cycler. You connect to it at night before bed, and it automatically fills and drains your belly over 8 to 10 hours while you sleep. You wake up with clean fluid out and waste gone. No daytime exchanges. No carrying bags. No stopping what you’re doing.
This is why many working adults, nurses, teachers, and parents choose APD. One ER nurse in Melbourne said it lets her work 12-hour shifts without worrying about when her next exchange is. She sleeps, the machine does the work, and she’s ready for her day.
Modern cyclers - like the Baxter Amia or Fresenius Sleep-Safe - are quieter than a library, weigh less than 25 pounds, and come with safety features that catch air bubbles, monitor pressure, and even send data to your clinic remotely. Some newer models use AI to adjust fluid removal based on your weight and blood pressure each day.
But APD has downsides too. If the machine breaks - and about 12% of cyclers do each year - you need to switch to manual exchanges right away. That’s stressful if you’re not trained for it. You also need a reliable power source, a bit of floor space, and you have to set up the machine every night. Some people say the noise, even if quiet, still disrupts their sleep. And if you’re traveling, you have to pack the cycler, which isn’t as easy as tossing a few bags in a bag.
Which One Is Better for Your Lifestyle?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But here’s how most people decide:
- Choose CAPD if: You’re active during the day, travel often, have limited space at home, don’t want to rely on electricity, and are physically able to handle the manual exchanges. It’s also often preferred for people over 75, because it’s simpler and doesn’t require learning how to operate a machine.
- Choose APD if: You work, care for kids, or just want to sleep through your treatment. You’re younger (under 65), have good hand strength, and want fewer daytime interruptions. APD also gives better fluid control, which means lower blood pressure and fewer hospital visits for fluid overload.
One big study from the Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation journal found APD users had 22% fewer emergencies related to fluid buildup. That’s huge. But CAPD users reported higher satisfaction with travel flexibility - 22% higher, according to a 2022 survey of 1,200 patients.
Cost, Training, and Support
Both types are covered by Medicare and most private insurers in Australia and the U.S. But out-of-pocket costs differ. CAPD supplies cost about $50-$75 a month. APD runs $75-$100 because you’re renting the cycler. Some programs cover the machine fully, so check with your provider.
Training is longer for APD - 14 to 21 days - because you have to learn how to use the machine, troubleshoot errors, and manage connections. CAPD training is shorter, 10 to 14 days, but it’s more physically demanding. You have to master sterile technique perfectly, or you risk infection.
Support is better for APD. Most clinics now offer 24/7 phone support for cycler issues, and 78% of APD programs use remote monitoring. That means if your machine stops working, your clinic knows before you even call. CAPD support is more reactive - you call when something goes wrong.
Real People, Real Choices
On patient forums, CAPD users love the freedom. One man wrote: “I took my dialysis bags to a beach in Byron Bay. No machine. No wires. Just me and the ocean.” But others say: “I’m tired of stopping everything to do an exchange. I miss full nights of sleep.”
APD users say: “I don’t think about dialysis during the day anymore.” But they also say: “I had a cycler fail at 2 a.m. I panicked. I didn’t know what to do.”
Neither is perfect. But both are life-changing compared to sitting in a clinic for four hours, three times a week.
What About the Future?
APD adoption is growing fast - up 7.3% a year. CAPD is only growing at 2.1%. Why? Because technology keeps improving. New cyclers can adjust your treatment automatically. Some can even connect to your phone. By 2030, APD will likely be the most common form of home PD.
But CAPD isn’t going away. It’s still the best option for older adults, people in rural areas with no reliable power, or those who just prefer doing things themselves. It’s low-tech, reliable, and doesn’t need a doctor’s visit every time something goes wrong.
Key Takeaways
- CAPD gives you daytime freedom but requires manual work and has a higher infection risk.
- APD lets you sleep through treatment, offers better fluid control, and has lower hospitalization rates - but depends on a machine that can break.
- Age matters: CAPD is often better for those over 75; APD suits working-age adults.
- Lifestyle matters: Travelers and active people lean toward CAPD. Those who want uninterrupted nights pick APD.
- Support is critical: Make sure your clinic offers 24/7 help, especially if you choose APD.
How to Decide
Ask yourself these questions:
- Do I have the strength and coordination to do manual exchanges every day?
- Can I handle a machine breaking in the middle of the night?
- Do I work, care for kids, or need to sleep through the night?
- Do I travel often? Can I carry a cycler?
- Is my home setup reliable - power, space, clean area?
Talk to your nephrologist. Ask for a trial. Some clinics let you try both for a week. See how each feels. Your body, your routine, your life - those matter more than what’s trending.
What If I Change My Mind?
You can switch. Many people start with CAPD and move to APD after a few months. Others start with APD and go back to CAPD if the machine causes too much stress. It’s not a life sentence. Your needs change. Your treatment can too.
Final Thought
Peritoneal dialysis isn’t just a medical procedure - it’s a way to live. CAPD and APD both give you back your life. The question isn’t which is better. It’s which one lets you live the way you want to live.
Can I do peritoneal dialysis if I work full-time?
Yes, absolutely. APD is designed for working people - it runs while you sleep. CAPD can also work if your job allows you to take short breaks for exchanges. Many nurses, teachers, and office workers manage both successfully. The key is planning your exchanges around your schedule.
Is peritoneal dialysis safer than hemodialysis?
It depends. PD avoids the blood pressure swings and heart stress that come with in-clinic hemodialysis. It’s gentler on your cardiovascular system. But PD carries a risk of peritonitis - an infection in the belly - if you don’t follow sterile technique. Hemodialysis has risks too, like infections at the access site. Both are safe when managed well. PD offers better long-term survival for many patients, especially those who stick with it.
Do I need to change my diet on peritoneal dialysis?
Yes, but less than with hemodialysis. Because PD removes waste and fluid more continuously, you can usually eat more potassium and phosphorus than on in-center dialysis. But you still need to watch sodium and fluids to avoid swelling and high blood pressure. A renal dietitian will help you tailor your meals. Most people on PD have more flexibility than those on hemodialysis.
How long does it take to learn peritoneal dialysis?
CAPD training takes 10 to 14 days. APD takes 14 to 21 days because you’re learning to use a machine. You’ll practice with a nurse every day until you’re confident. Most people feel comfortable doing it alone after a couple of weeks. Don’t rush - safety is more important than speed.
What happens if the APD cycler breaks?
You switch to manual CAPD exchanges until the machine is fixed. All APD patients are trained to do this. Most clinics provide backup supplies and 24/7 support. If your cycler fails at night, call your clinic - they’ll walk you through it. Some cyclers even send automatic alerts to your care team when something’s wrong.
Can I travel with peritoneal dialysis?
Yes. CAPD is easier to travel with - just pack your dialysis bags and supplies. APD requires the cycler, which you can ship ahead or rent at your destination. Many clinics help arrange supplies overseas. Some airlines allow you to bring the cycler as medical equipment. Always plan ahead and talk to your care team before you leave.
Is peritoneal dialysis right for older adults?
CAPD is often recommended for older adults, especially over 75, because it doesn’t require operating a machine. If you have trouble with your hands or memory, APD may be harder. But some older patients do well with APD if they have a caregiver to help with setup. It’s not about age - it’s about your physical ability, support system, and personal preference.
